Melbourne’s independent food critic

Where to Eat, Honestly

310 restaurants reviewed since 2016. I book under another name, visit at least twice and pay every bill in full.

Critic's picks

The Best Tables This Month

The three places I would send a friend to this weekend, scored out of ten.

All Reviews
Critic's Pick 9.1 / 10
Seafood Fitzroy

Ostra

$$$

A raw bar that treats oysters like a tasting menu. Book the counter, order the crudo and save room for the burnt honey tart.

Read the Review: Ostra
Near you

Every Review on One Map

Filter by cuisine, area, price or score, then find the one closest to you.

Full Map

9 restaurants

  1. Seafood · Fitzroy · $$$

    Ostra

    48 Harbour Lane, Fitzroy VIC 3065

    9.1
  2. Italian · Carlton · $$$

    The Long Table

    212 Lygon Street, Carlton

    8.9
  3. Indian · Richmond · $$

    Saffron Room

    301 Victoria Street, Richmond

    8.8
  4. Steakhouse · City Centre · $$$$

    Butcher’s Table

    27 Flinders Lane, Melbourne

    8.6
  5. Japanese · City Centre · $

    Lantern Ramen Bar

    18 Little Bourke Street, Melbourne

    8.4
  6. Café · Brunswick · $$

    Laneway Canteen

    402 Sydney Road, Brunswick

    8.2
  7. Mexican · Brunswick · $

    Taco Social

    77 Lygon Street, Brunswick East

    7.9
  8. Modern Australian · Williamstown · $$$$

    Harbour & Vine

    9 Nelson Place, Williamstown

    7.6
  9. Brunch · Richmond · $$

    Sunny Side Diner

    150 Swan Street, Richmond

    7.4
Ranked and mapped

Best-Of Guides

Where I would send a friend, by dish and by suburb, updated as places open and close.

All Guides
  • Fitzroy
  • Every kind

Where to Eat in Fitzroy

From the oyster bar on Harbour Lane to the late-night dumplings on Brunswick Street.

Updated

The method

How I Score a Meal

Four scores out of ten, weighted toward what is on the plate. A 9 is rare, and a 10 hasn't happened yet.

  • Food

    Half the score. Is it delicious, is it cooked with care, and would I order it again?

  • Service

    A fifth. Warm, informed and paced right, whether it is a counter or a dining room.

  • The Room

    Light, noise, comfort and the feeling of the place on a busy night.

  • Value

    Not cheap, but fair: does the price match the care on the plate?

Got a Tip? Tell Me Where to Eat

Half my best reviews started with a reader’s message. Tell me about the place you can’t stop talking about.

Buy Theme (opens in a new tab)